And breathe… The nature of being a Saints fan in recent times had me discounting none of the permutations that could have seen Saints drop out of the Premier League yesterday evening. A 5-0 defeat to the 100-point-searching Champions seemed eminently possible. Likewise, I kidded myself into believing that a hapless Swansea team who hadn’t scored in their last 4 league games could suddenly rout already-relegated Stoke 5-0. Thankfully my pessimism has been blown apart, Stoke having one last Premier League hurrah, and Saints falling to a last second Gabriel Jesus winner, performing admirably against the expensively assembled Manchester City.
I won’t attempt to dissect this bitterly disappointing season – I did as much when I justified why Pellegrino’s time was up – instead, it’s time to discuss what needs to happen in the summer in order to improve the culture at the club and ensure Southampton avoid the same fate next season.
Leadership
A feature closely associated with Southampton Football Club in recent times has been transparency from the top down. The Liebherrs, Cortese, Reed and Krueger have been open and honest with the fanbase about where they see the club going and in what timescale that can be achieved. The ‘Five Year Plan’ to return Southampton to the Premier League was executed in just three years: JPT triumph at Wembley in front of a beaming Markus Liebherr was followed by back-to-back promotions.
Saints then set their sights a little higher – sacking the affable Adkins and replacing him with little-known Argentinian Pochettino proved inspired, propelling Southampton to the upper echelons of the league. Champions League football was the (perhaps unrealistic) target:
“We’d like to think we have the structure to [reach the Champions League] in the next five years.” Les Reed, April 2015
After several seasons of further progression, the poaching of fan favourites Pochettino and Koeman meant the managerial hunt had to begin again, and it’s in this task that the board failed spectacularly. The appointments of first Puel then Pellegrino were an alarming departure from the attacking intensity instilled by the former two managers. Puel made Saints harder to break down, but Saints forgot how to score under his stewardship and the Frenchman’s team slowly slipped down the table. Pellegrino’s credentials were no better, and his apparent lack of any game plan at all soon had supporters baying for his blood too.
In the cut and thrust world of Premier League football, some might admire the board’s persistence with Pellegrino, but the fact is he overstayed his welcome at Southampton and should have been sacked many months before his eventual dismissal with just 8 games of the season to go.
While safety has been secured by the finest of margins, this complacency was driven by the board a.) making poor appointments and b.) not wishing to hold their hands up to these mistakes. There certainly hasn’t been an admission to these failings – Reed and Krueger, who are both all too happy to be the mouthpiece of the club in the great times, have remained silent in the shadows as we continue our sharp decline.
The club is now under 80% Chinese ownership, but Mr Gao has yet to communicate directly with the club’s fans. There seems a blatant disconnect between the lifeblood of the club and those that oversee its existence. This summer, we need some strong statements from those in positions of power on where they see the club going, giving fans something to strive towards. Are we content with simply staying up, or can we get to the next level?
Manager
There came a point earlier this season when I started to fall out of love with Southampton. I’m not fickle enough to do that simply because results weren’t going our way, no, this was because the football on show was dull and unimaginative, and the players looked shockingly disinterested. This was a group of players who could see the trap door beckoning but, quite frankly, didn’t care. Mark Hughes’ appointment has turned out to be just the tonic for Southampton – while he hasn’t revolutionised the playing style, he’s brought the passion back. The players finally care again, and are playing as a unit rather than as undoubtedly talented but wildly underachieving individuals.
For me, it’s essential Southampton keep Hughes this summer. The players and fans are fully behind ‘Sparky’ – only 8 games under his leadership and he’s achieved something neither Puel nor Pellegrino could; his name echoes around St.Mary’s on match days.
In the long-term, I’d like to see us appoint another young, ambitious coach in the vein of Pochettino who fosters exciting, attacking football. For the moment though, Hughes seems just the ticket to steady the ship and reestablish Southampton as top 10 material.
Captain
Southampton desperately need to end the trend of bestowing the honour of captaincy on a player desperate to leave. Virgil Van Dijk was given captaincy in the midst of his angling for transfer to Liverpool. Current captain Ryan Bertrand too has looked disinterested at times this season, and I’m almost certain he will leave the club this summer. Saints have lacked leaders on the pitch this year – the new captain will need to lead from the front and be fully committed to this club. Step forward Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg.
The Dane has been excellent when called upon and must surely be one of the first names on the team sheet next season. Comfortable on the ball with an impressive range of passing and willing to put his body on the line, it’s his character that shines through – I love that he’s willing to front up to poor performances and is articulate and passionate in press conferences. I would be delighted if he’s give the captaincy for 2018/19 and beyond.
Others worthy of mention would be midfield bulldog Romeu and one of our very own, James Ward-Prowse. The former dominates the midfield and has been vocal about his love of Southampton, whilst the latter has captained England U21s and has turned in some very impressive performances this season. Whoever is selected as manager has a big decision to make.
Team
I don’t feel a complete overhaul is needed – as mentioned earlier, we have the basis of a talented squad, we just need to get them playing quality football. Having said that, there are still some key transfers (both in and out) we need to get over the line this summer. Offers are likely to come in for Ryan Bertrand and, provided they’re big, I’d thank Ryan for his service and wave him on his way – he looks like he craves a move to a big team, and with Targett and McQueen waiting in line, I don’t see replacing him as too much of an issue.
Guido Carrillo – abject failure
Meanwhile, the signing of Guido Carrillo looks exceedingly poor – the £19 million man hasn’t scored for the club and no longer even makes the bench. We’ll undoubtedly make a loss on him, but hopefully we’ll soon be saying farewell to the striker. I mean, he might get a bad rep, but at least Ali Dia came close to scoring.
Fraser Forster is another we need to usher out of the door. ‘The Wall’ was just that during his first season and a half at St.Mary’s, and deservedly challenged for the England number 1 shirt. The last few years have been quite the opposite and, after flaps and fumbles aplenty, he was finally usurped by the hugely impressive Alex McCarthy. Therein lies the issue – after signing a new five-year contract last summer, Saints now have one of their highest paid players languishing on the bench. Easier said than done, but we have to try and find a way to get this drain on resources to move on this summer.
And so to new signings. For me there are three main priorities:
Centre Back – while this was a position of strength in recent times – Van Dijk replaced Alderweireld who replaced Lovren – we currently lack a centre back of the highest quality to partner one of Stephens, Bednarek or Hoedt. I think this is the priority, and hope we break our transfer record to secure the appropriate signing.
Sisto – on his way to Saints?
Winger – in the mould of Mane, we need a pacy winger who is unafraid to take on their man (ahem, Redmond…) and has an eye for goal. The likes of Quincy Promes and particularly Pione Sisto appeal to me.
Striker – with Gabbiadini and Carillo likely to pack their bags and never return, a goalscorer is needed to ease the burden on Charlie Austin up top. For the second successive season, no player has reached double figures in the league. It’s time for the black box to earn its corn once more and find us a gem.
So onwards and upwards I say. Come on you Saints.